We're still shipping - Enjoy 20% off your order today.Supporting American sex lives by continuing to deliver your orders safely. Valid this visit only. 1st order only. Exclusions apply.
1866 786 4081
Shipping: $8.95 DHL Express 2 - 3 business days. Includes delays due to COVID-19
COVID-19
Log In
Register
Products
  • Products
Free express delivery over $80
Easy returns
Discreet packaging
Earn loyalty dollars
Paypal + Credit card
Home/Anal Toys/Butt Plugs

Butt Plugs

Gone is the stigma of anal sex and now is the time to embrace the delights of anal sex toys. Butt plugs come in a variety of shapes, sizes and materials. From silicone to glass to vibrating and pulsating you are bound to find a butt plug perfect for you. Butt plugs are perfect for those who are building themselves up for anal sex and they are also great when inserted during intercourse and oral sex. Our anal collection includes butt plugs, anal beads and anal vibrators that are guaranteed to titillate and tantalise.
Filter
Sort
Colour:
Price:
< $20
$20 - $40
$40 - $60
$60 - $80
$80 - $100
$100 - $150
$150 - $200
$200 - $300
$300 +
Tag:
Length:
Girth:
Sort By:
Popular
Lowest Price
Highest Price
New Product
Product Name
Anal Toys Categories
Silicone Butt Plug
Sale

Silicone Butt Plug

Earn $0.40 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
4.8 (30)
$7.95USD
Sale 34% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $1.99
Share Satisfaction Medium Curved Plug
Sale

Share Satisfaction Medium Curved Plug

Earn $0.40 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.6 (38)
4 Colours
$7.95USD
Sale 51% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $1.99
Share Satisfaction Anal Trainer Kit
Sale

Share Satisfaction Anal Trainer Kit

Earn $0.90 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.0
4.2 (15)
$18.95USD
Sale 41% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $4.74
Finger butt plug
Sale

Finger Butt Plug

Earn $0.20 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.0
4.1 (13)
$4.95USD
Sale 38% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $1.24
Kink Range Metal Rose Butt Plug  32 Inch
Sale
2 Colours
$23.95USD
Sale 41% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $5.99
Kink Range Metal Rose Butt Plug  3 Inch
Sale
2 Colours
$23.95USD
Sale 41% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $5.99
Share Satisfaction Large Curved Plug
Sale

Share Satisfaction Large Curved Plug

Earn $0.90 Loyalty Dollars
4 Colours
$18.95USD
Sale 14% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $4.74
Share Satisfaction Large Silicone Butt Plug
Sale
3 Colours
$5.95USD
Sale 76% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $1.49
Kink Range Metal Rose Butt Plug
Sale

Kink Range Metal Rose Butt Plug

Earn $1.40 Loyalty Dollars
2 Colours
$27.95USD
Sale 45% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $6.99
Suction Gnome Butt Plug
Sale

Suction Gnome Butt Plug

Earn $1.20 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.0
4.2 (3)
3 Sizes
$23.95USD
Sale 15% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $5.99
Share Satisfaction Medium Silicone Butt Plug
Sale

Share Satisfaction Medium Silicone Butt Plug

Earn $0.80 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (1)
4 Colours
$15.95USD
Sale 21% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.99
Blaster Anal Plug
Sale

Blaster Anal Plug

Earn $0.80 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.0
4.1 (4)
3 Sizes
$16.95USD
Sale 16% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $4.24
Share Satisfaction Small Curved Plug
Sale

Share Satisfaction Small Curved Plug

Earn $0.30 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
4 Colours
$5.95USD
Sale 63% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $1.49
Share Satisfaction Small Silicone Butt Plug
Sale
3 Colours
$11.95USD
Sale 58% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $2.99
Share Satisfaction 3 Piece Plug Kit
Clearance

Share Satisfaction 3 Piece Plug Kit

Earn $2.00 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (4)
$39.95USD
Sale 29% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $9.99
Gum Drop Anal Plug
Sale

Gum Drop Anal Plug

Earn $0.70 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (3)
$13.95USD
Sale 42% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.49
Mesmerizing Gem Plug  28 inch
Sale

Mesmerizing Gem Plug - 2.8 Inch

Earn $0.80 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
4 Colours
$15.95USD
Sale 45% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.99
Booty Bliss Butt Plug
Sale

Booty Bliss Butt Plug

Earn $0.70 Loyalty Dollars
2 Colours
$13.95USD
Sale 23% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.49
Fox Tail Butt Plug
Sale

Fox Tail Butt Plug

Earn $1.80 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.4 (2)
3 Colours
$36.95USD
Sale 22% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $9.24
Late Night Pleasure Kit
Sale

Late Night Pleasure Kit

Earn $1.60 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (7)
$31.95USD
Sale 34% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.99
Beginners Butt Plug
Sale

Beginners Butt Plug

Earn $0.60 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.6 (80)
$12.95USD
Sale 36% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.24
Mini Sucker Butt Plug
Sale

Mini Sucker Butt Plug

Earn $0.70 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.5 (21)
$14.95USD
Sale 26% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.74
Lucent Opula Glass Massager
Sale

Lucent Opula Glass Massager

Earn $1.40 Loyalty Dollars
$27.95USD
Sale 13% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $6.99
Candy Butt Plug
Sale

Candy Butt Plug

Earn $0.70 Loyalty Dollars
$14.95USD
Sale 54% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.74
Firefly Trainer Kit Multicolor
Sale

Firefly Trainer Kit Multicolor

Earn $1.40 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (3)
$27.95USD
Sale 10% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $6.99
Bubbles Bumpy Starter Anal Plug
Sale

Bubbles Bumpy Starter Anal Plug

Earn $0.60 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (17)
$12.95USD
Sale 19% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.24
Candy Butt Plug  4 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Candy Butt Plug - 4 Inch

Earn $4.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$11.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $2.99
Roll Play Plug
Sale

Roll Play Plug

Earn $1.00 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.0
4.0 (1)
$19.95USD
Sale 29% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $4.99
Gemmed Silicone Anal Plug  28 Inch
Sale

Gemmed Silicone Anal Plug - 2.8 Inch

Earn $1.00 Loyalty Dollars
$19.95USD
Sale 51% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $4.99
Candy Butt Plug  51 Inch
Sale

Candy Butt Plug - 5.1 Inch

Earn $0.40 Loyalty Dollars
2 Colours
$7.95USD
Sale 51% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $1.99
Gun Drops Plug
Sale

Gun Drops Plug

Earn $0.40 Loyalty Dollars
3 Colours
$7.95USD
Sale 34% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $1.99
Seven Creations Rider Butt Plug Set
Sale

Seven Creations Rider Butt Plug Set

Earn $1.40 Loyalty Dollars
$27.95USD
Sale 18% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $6.99
Lucent Magica Glass Butt Plug
Sale

Lucent Magica Glass Butt Plug

Earn $1.40 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
4.9 (7)
$27.95USD
Sale 13% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $6.99
Gemmed Silicone Anal Plug  28 Inch
Sale

Gemmed Silicone Anal Plug - 2.8 Inch

Earn $1.00 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (1)
$19.95USD
Sale 51% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $4.99
Kink Range Tail Butt Plug  29 Inches
Sale

Kink Range Tail Butt Plug - 2.9 Inches

Earn $1.00 Loyalty Dollars
$20.95USD
Sale 57% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $5.24
Stag Kaufmann Butt Plug  53 Inch
Sale

Stag Kaufmann Butt Plug - 5.3 Inch

Earn $0.70 Loyalty Dollars
$14.95USD
Sale 7% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.74
Kink Range Jewelled Triple Bulb Butt Plug  54 Inch
Sale
$27.95USD
Sale 31% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $6.99
Kink Range Gemmed Plug  31 Inch
Sale

Kink Range Gemmed Plug - 3.1 Inch

Earn $0.70 Loyalty Dollars
$13.95USD
Sale 37% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.49
Petite Yucie  36 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Petite Yucie - 3.6 Inch

Earn $7.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$15.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.99
Gosling Todt Butt Plug  4 Inch
Sale

Gosling Todt Butt Plug - 4 Inch

Earn $0.40 Loyalty Dollars
$7.95USD
Sale 39% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $1.99
Hiney Rod Butt Plug  61 Inch
Sale

Hiney Rod Butt Plug - 6.1 Inch

Earn $0.70 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$13.95USD
Sale 13% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.49
Kink Range Emoji Butt Plug  28 Inch
Sale

Kink Range Emoji Butt Plug - 2.8 Inch

Earn $0.40 Loyalty Dollars
$7.95USD
Sale 61% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $1.99
Kink Range Gemmed Plug  28 Inch
Sale

Kink Range Gemmed Plug - 2.8 Inch

Earn $1.00 Loyalty Dollars
$19.95USD
Sale 60% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $4.99
Mini Anal Start Butt Plug  45 Inch
Sale

Mini Anal Start Butt Plug - 4.5 Inch

Earn $0.40 Loyalty Dollars
$8.95USD
Sale 44% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $2.24
Kink Range Gemmed Plug  28 Inch
Sale

Kink Range Gemmed Plug - 2.8 Inch

Earn $0.60 Loyalty Dollars
$11.95USD
Sale 41% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $2.99
Kink Range Jewelled Bulb Butt Plug  41 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Kink Range Jewelled Bulb Butt Plug - 4.1 Inch

Earn $13.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$27.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $6.99
Platinum Premium Silicone The Minis Spade Small
Sale

Platinum Premium Silicone The Minis Spade Small

Earn $0.70 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
4.9 (3)
2 Colours
$14.95USD
Sale 17% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.74
Dosha 3 Piece Glass Anal Plug Kit
Sale

Dosha 3 Piece Glass Anal Plug Kit

Earn $2.00 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (6)
$39.95USD
Sale 45% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $9.99
Glams Mini Gem Plug  33 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Glams Mini Gem Plug - 3.3 Inch

Earn $3.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.3 (2)
$15.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.99
SASSY Anal Plug
Sale

Sassy Anal Plug

Earn $0.20 Loyalty Dollars
2 Colours
$4.95USD
Sale 38% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $1.24
Candy Butt Plug  27 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Candy Butt Plug - 2.7 Inch

Earn $7.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.0
3.8 (3)
2 Colours
$11.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $2.99
Evil Dildo Plug  49 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Evil Dildo Plug - 4.9 Inch

Earn $5.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$12.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.24
Kink Range Jewelled Double Bulb Butt Plug  41 Inch
Sale
$15.95USD
Sale 43% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.99
Firefly Prince Glow Plug
Sale

Firefly Prince Glow Plug

Earn $0.50 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.0
4.2 (3)
3 Colours
$10.95USD
Sale 16% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $2.74
Plum Drop Starter Anal Plug
Sale

Plum Drop Starter Anal Plug

Earn $0.60 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$12.95USD
Sale 19% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.24
Renegade Spades Small
Sale

Renegade Spades Small

Earn $0.70 Loyalty Dollars
$13.95USD
Sale 31% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.49
Beg Anal Plug  27 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Beg Anal Plug - 2.7 Inch

Earn $5.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (2)
$12.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.24
Lovelife by OhMiBod Dare Curved Pleasure Plug
Bonus Loyalty

Lovelife By Ohmibod Dare Curved Pleasure Plug

Earn $41.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$84.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $21.24
bvibe Snug Plug 3
Sale

B-vibe Snug Plug 3

Earn $3.20 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (5)
2 Colours
$63.95USD
Sale 49% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $15.99
Lovelife by OhMiBod Explore Pleasure Plug
Sale
$39.95USD
Sale 49% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $9.99
Booty Call Booty Rocker Butt Plug
Sale

Booty Call Booty Rocker Butt Plug

Earn $0.50 Loyalty Dollars
rating 3.5
3.7 (2)
3 Colours. 2 Sizes
$10.95USD
Sale 43% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $2.74
Large Anal Plug
Bonus Loyalty

Large Anal Plug

Earn $14.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
4.9 (4)
$35.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $8.99
Renegade Spades Extra Large
Sale

Renegade Spades Extra Large

Earn $1.20 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.0
4.0 (2)
$23.95USD
Sale 18% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $5.99
Dina Silicone Butt Plug
Sale

Dina Silicone Butt Plug

Earn $0.60 Loyalty Dollars
$11.95USD
Sale 30% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $2.99
Love Plug
Sale

Love Plug

Earn $0.70 Loyalty Dollars
$13.95USD
Sale 27% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.49
Power Gem Vibrating Crystal Probe
Bonus Loyalty

Power Gem Vibrating Crystal Probe

Earn $9.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (1)
3 Colours
$55.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $13.99
bvibe Snug Plug 4
Sale

B-vibe Snug Plug 4

Earn $3.40 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (6)
$67.95USD
Sale 49% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $16.99
Firefly Pleasure Plug Mini Pink
Sale

Firefly Pleasure Plug Mini Pink

Earn $0.70 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
4.9 (2)
$13.95USD
Sale 7% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.49
Pretty Ends Iridescent Butt Plug Small
Bonus Loyalty

Pretty Ends Iridescent Butt Plug Small

Earn $3.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 2.5
2.4 (2)
$14.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.74
Classic Butt Plug Smooth
Sale

Classic Butt Plug Smooth

Earn $0.60 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (2)
$12.95USD
Sale 72% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.24
Kink Range Dolphine Metal Anal Plug  37 Inch
Sale

Kink Range Dolphine Metal Anal Plug - 3.7 Inch

Earn $0.80 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (1)
$15.95USD
Sale 60% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.99
Kink Range Silicone Gemmed Butt Plug  31 Inch
Sale

Kink Range Silicone Gemmed Butt Plug - 3.1 Inch

Earn $0.70 Loyalty Dollars
rating 3.5
3.7 (1)
$13.95USD
Sale 37% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.49
Page 1 of 7
Butt Plugs Articles
More
advanced anal toys
If you're getting bored of your beginner butt plug it's time to upgrade! These anal plugs are suited for more advanced anal players looking to take things to the next level. .
Posted in Sex Toy Guides
Butt Plugs
IMG 0001 3
Hollow, or tunnel, butt plugs can be a great addition to your collection if you like anal play. Let's take a look at what they are and how to use them!!.
Posted in Sex Toy Guides
Butt Plugs
Butt plug anal toys
Long time fantasizer and first time user? Here are step-by-step instructions of how to use a butt plug for the very first time! .
Posted in Sex Toy Guides
Butt Plugs
The Heat Sex ArticlesThe Heat Sex Articles
Guest
16th June 2022
rating 4.0
Verified Purchaser
Had what I wanted at a good price. The only bad thing about the store is that it shipped from NEW ZEALAND and it took FOREVER for it to get here (by Chicago). didn't know this till they notified me about the shipment.UGH!
Guest
14th June 2022
rating 5.0
Verified Purchaser
Well packaged! I was very impressed by how quickly it arrived after learning it came all the way from New Zealand. Very affordable, and great quality toys. Extremely satisfied. I will be buying from ATMS again.
Rachel
9th June 2022
rating 5.0
Verified Purchaser
They have a great selection of items to choose from. Very good quality, and I received it very promptly. Definitely will be ordering from them again
Matt
8th June 2022
rating 5.0
Verified Purchaser
Shipping was prompt and packaging was sustainable.
Subscribe and be in to win a Cosmopolitan gift pack.Value $475.60. Valid all July. T&C's apply

TOP