We're still shipping - Enjoy 20% off your order today.Supporting American sex lives by continuing to deliver your orders safely. Valid this visit only. 1st order only. Exclusions apply.
1866 786 4081
Shipping: $8.95 DHL Express 2 - 3 business days. Includes delays due to COVID-19
COVID-19
Log In
Register
Products
  • Products
Free express delivery over $80
Easy returns
Discreet packaging
Earn loyalty dollars
Paypal + Credit card
Home/Anal Toys/Butt Plug Tails

Butt Plug Tails

Just as the name suggests, butt plug tails consist of a butt plug (glass, metal, silicone or rubber) which is inserted into the anus, and a tail part that that falls gentle outside the anus giving the look of a real animal tail. The advantage of the butt plug tails, (aside from its feature as a butt plug) is that it offers fairly realistic tail movements and the attachment point is not easily seen. A butt plug tail can give the impression that your special animal has a real tail.
Filter
Sort
Colour:
Price:
< $20
$20 - $40
$40 - $60
$60 - $80
$80 - $100
$100 - $150
$150 - $200
$200 - $300
$300 +
Tag:
Length:
Girth:
Sort By:
Popular
Lowest Price
Highest Price
New Product
Product Name
Anal Toys Categories
Kink Range Tail Butt Plug  29 Inches
Sale

Kink Range Tail Butt Plug - 2.9 Inches

Earn $1.00 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.3 (1)
$19.95USD
Sale 59% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $4.99
Fox Tail Butt Plug
Sale

Fox Tail Butt Plug

Earn $1.80 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.4 (2)
3 Colours
$36.95USD
Sale 22% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $9.24
Kink Range Bushy Tail Skeleton Fur Butt Plug  29 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Kink Range Bushy Tail Skeleton Fur Butt Plug - 2.9 Inch

Earn $12.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$65.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $16.49
Bunny Tail Plug
Sale

Bunny Tail Plug

Earn $1.60 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.0
4.0 (1)
2 Colours
$31.95USD
Sale 26% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.99
Foxy Anal Tail Plug  133 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Foxy Anal Tail Plug - 13.3 Inch

Earn $4.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$15.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.99
Kink Range Bushy Tail Butt Plug  3 Inch
Sale

Kink Range Bushy Tail Butt Plug - 3 Inch

Earn $0.90 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
3 Colours
$18.95USD
Sale 57% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $4.74
Kink Range Tail Butt Plug  29 Inches
Sale

Kink Range Tail Butt Plug - 2.9 Inches

Earn $1.00 Loyalty Dollars
$20.95USD
Sale 57% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $5.24
KinKi Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug  59 Inch
Sale
$29.95USD
Sale 22% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.49
Kink Range Bushy Tail Skeleton Fur Butt Plug  29 Inch
Sale
$15.95USD
Sale 67% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.99
KinKi Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug  59 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Kinki Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug - 5.9 Inch

Earn $8.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$37.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $9.49
KinKi Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug  59 Inch
Sale
$29.95USD
Sale 22% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.49
KinKi Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug  59 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Kinki Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug - 5.9 Inch

Earn $8.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$37.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $9.49
KinKi Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug  59 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Kinki Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug - 5.9 Inch

Earn $8.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$37.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $9.49
KinKi Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug  59 Inch
Sale
$29.95USD
Sale 22% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.49
KinKi Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug  59 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Kinki Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug - 5.9 Inch

Earn $8.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$37.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $9.49
Kink Range Tail Butt Plug  29 Inches
Sale

Kink Range Tail Butt Plug - 2.9 Inches

Earn $2.70 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
2 Colours
$53.95USD
Sale 20% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $13.49
KinKi Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug  59 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Kinki Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug - 5.9 Inch

Earn $8.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$37.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $9.49
KinKi Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug  59 Inch
Clearance

Kinki Rainbow Rabbit Tail Plug - 5.9 Inch

Earn $1.50 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.0
4.0 (1)
$29.95USD
Sale 22% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.49
Kink Range Tail Butt Plug  29 Inches
Bonus Loyalty

Kink Range Tail Butt Plug - 2.9 Inches

Earn $29.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.0
4.0 (1)
$47.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $11.99
Kink Range Tail Butt Plug  29 Inches
Sale

Kink Range Tail Butt Plug - 2.9 Inches

Earn $0.60 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$11.95USD
Sale 77% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $2.99
Kink Range Tail Butt Plug  29 Inches
Sale

Kink Range Tail Butt Plug - 2.9 Inches

Earn $0.80 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
4.8 (3)
$15.95USD
Sale 55% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.99
Tailz Fox Tail  Ears Set
Bonus Loyalty

Tailz Fox Tail & Ears Set

Earn $27.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (2)
$87.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $21.99
Tantalizing Foxy Anal Plug
Bonus Loyalty

Tantalizing Foxy Anal Plug

Earn $14.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$27.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $6.99
Striped Butt Plug Tail
Sale

Striped Butt Plug Tail

Earn $2.70 Loyalty Dollars
$53.95USD
Sale 19% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $13.49
Kink Range Tail Butt Plug  29 Inches
Sale

Kink Range Tail Butt Plug - 2.9 Inches

Earn $0.90 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$17.95USD
Sale 63% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $4.49
Fluffy Bunny Tail Anal Plug
Sale

Fluffy Bunny Tail Anal Plug

Earn $1.50 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$30.95USD
Sale 33% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.74
Fox Tail Anal Plug
Bonus Loyalty

Fox Tail Anal Plug

Earn $5.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.3 (6)
$42.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $10.74
Bunny Tail
Sale

Bunny Tail

Earn $1.40 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.5 (2)
$27.95USD
Sale 42% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $6.99
Tailz Onyx Bunny Tail Anal Plug
Sale

Tailz Onyx Bunny Tail Anal Plug

Earn $1.40 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.3 (3)
$27.95USD
Sale 38% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $6.99
Kink Range Tail Butt Plug  29 Inches
Sale

Kink Range Tail Butt Plug - 2.9 Inches

Earn $0.80 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (1)
$15.95USD
Sale 70% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.99
Tailz Vibrating White Fox Tail Slender Anal Plug  18 Inch
Bonus Loyalty
$105.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $26.49
Unicorn Tails
Sale

Unicorn Tails

Earn $2.10 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$41.95USD
Sale 45% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $10.49
Bunny Tails Mini Black Fur Black
Sale

Bunny Tails Mini Black Fur Black

Earn $1.20 Loyalty Dollars
$23.95USD
Sale 15% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $5.99
Pedigree Puppy Play Tail Plug
Sale

Pedigree Puppy Play Tail Plug

Earn $2.00 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$39.95USD
Sale 51% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $9.99
BLONDIES PONY TAIL BUTT PLUG
Sale

Blondies Pony Tail Butt Plug

Earn $1.80 Loyalty Dollars
rating 3.5
3.7 (2)
$35.95USD
Sale 19% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $8.99
Rainbow Tail Silicone Anal Plug
Sale

Rainbow Tail Silicone Anal Plug

Earn $3.40 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (1)
$67.95USD
Sale 39% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $16.99
Unicorn Tails Rainbow Plug
Sale

Unicorn Tails Rainbow Plug

Earn $2.20 Loyalty Dollars
$43.95USD
Sale 9% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $10.99
Metal Bunny Butt Plug
Bonus Loyalty

Metal Bunny Butt Plug

Earn $6.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.0
4.0 (1)
$35.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $8.99
Unicorn Tail
Bonus Loyalty

Unicorn Tail

Earn $36.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$71.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $17.99
Reds  Leather Butt Plug And Whip Medium
Sale

Reds Leather Butt Plug And Whip Medium

Earn $2.00 Loyalty Dollars
$39.95USD
Sale 17% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $9.99
Tailz White Fluffy Bunny Tail Anal Plug
Bonus Loyalty

Tailz White Fluffy Bunny Tail Anal Plug

Earn $15.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (2)
$45.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $11.49
No13 Butt Plug 6 Inch
Sale

No13 Butt Plug 6 Inch

Earn $1.60 Loyalty Dollars
$31.95USD
Sale 24% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.99
No12 Butt Plug 4 Inch
Sale

No12 Butt Plug 4 Inch

Earn $0.80 Loyalty Dollars
$15.95USD
Sale 24% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.99
Fluffer Bunny Tail Glass Anal Plug
Clearance

Fluffer Bunny Tail Glass Anal Plug

Earn $1.80 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$35.95USD
Sale 50% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $8.99
KinKi Foxy Tail Butt Plug  336 Inch
Sale

Kinki Foxy Tail Butt Plug - 33.6 Inch

Earn $2.60 Loyalty Dollars
$52.95USD
Sale 24% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $13.24
Bunny Tail Anal Plug
Sale

Bunny Tail Anal Plug

Earn $1.00 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$20.95USD
Sale 17% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $5.24
KinKi Bushy Tail Butt Plug  206 Inch
Sale

Kinki Bushy Tail Butt Plug - 20.6 Inch

Earn $1.50 Loyalty Dollars
$29.95USD
Sale 22% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.49
KinKi Foxy Tail Butt Plug  336 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Kinki Foxy Tail Butt Plug - 33.6 Inch

Earn $16.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$69.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $17.49
Silicone Bunny Butt Plug
Sale

Silicone Bunny Butt Plug

Earn $1.40 Loyalty Dollars
$28.95USD
Sale 18% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.24
Bunny Tails Mini White Fur
Bonus Loyalty

Bunny Tails Mini White Fur

Earn $4.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$27.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $6.99
No11 Butt Plug 6 Inch
Sale

No11 Butt Plug 6 Inch

Earn $1.60 Loyalty Dollars
$31.95USD
Sale 16% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.99
Dog Tail Butt Plug
Sale

Dog Tail Butt Plug

Earn $2.70 Loyalty Dollars
$53.95USD
Sale 42% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $13.49
No15 Butt Plug 6 Inch
Sale

No15 Butt Plug 6 Inch

Earn $1.40 Loyalty Dollars
$28.95USD
Sale 24% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.24
Bunny Tails Mini Pink Fur
Bonus Loyalty

Bunny Tails Mini Pink Fur

Earn $4.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$27.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $6.99
No14 Butt Plug 4 Inch
Sale

No14 Butt Plug 4 Inch

Earn $1.10 Loyalty Dollars
$21.95USD
Sale 19% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $5.49
Tailz Rainbow Unicorn Tail Anal Plug  24 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

Tailz Rainbow Unicorn Tail Anal Plug - 24 Inch

Earn $22.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$57.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $14.49
Chrystalino Tail
Sale

Chrystalino Tail

Earn $2.40 Loyalty Dollars
2 Colours
$47.95USD
Sale 28% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $11.99
Tailz Purple Pony Tail Anal Plug
Sale

Tailz Purple Pony Tail Anal Plug

Earn $1.60 Loyalty Dollars
$32.95USD
Sale 41% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $8.24
Brunette Pony Tail Anal Plug
Sale

Brunette Pony Tail Anal Plug

Earn $1.40 Loyalty Dollars
$28.95USD
Sale 40% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.24
Fox Tail Glass Anal Plug
Sale

Fox Tail Glass Anal Plug

Earn $2.20 Loyalty Dollars
$44.95USD
Sale 20% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $11.24
Chrystalino Whipster
Sale

Chrystalino Whipster

Earn $2.20 Loyalty Dollars
2 Colours
$43.95USD
Sale 34% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $10.99
Sono No 10 4 Inch Butt Plug with Tail
Sale

Sono No 10 4 Inch Butt Plug With Tail

Earn $0.80 Loyalty Dollars
$16.95USD
Sale 30% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $4.24
No9 Butt Plug 6 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

No9 Butt Plug 6 Inch

Earn $7.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
2 Colours. 2 Sizes
$37.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $9.49
No8 Butt Plug 4 Inch
Bonus Loyalty

No8 Butt Plug 4 Inch

Earn $4.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
$19.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $4.99
Foxxxy Fanny Vibrating White Tail Anal Plug
Bonus Loyalty

Foxxxy Fanny Vibrating White Tail Anal Plug

Earn $2.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (4)
$63.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $15.99
Untamed XL Fox Tail Anal Plug
Sale

Untamed Xl Fox Tail Anal Plug

Earn $4.30 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$85.95USD
Sale 6% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $21.49
Icicles No 49
Sale

Icicles No 49

Earn $3.20 Loyalty Dollars
rating 4.5
4.7 (2)
$63.95USD
Sale 2% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $15.99
ALIEN TAIL Tail Butt plug and Sling
Bonus Loyalty

Alien Tail Tail Butt Plug And Sling

Earn $23.00 Bonus Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
4.9 (2)
$119.95USD
 
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $29.99
No12 Butt Plug 4 Inch
Sale

No12 Butt Plug 4 Inch

Earn $0.80 Loyalty Dollars
rating 5.0
5.0 (1)
$15.95USD
Sale 24% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $3.99
No12 Butt Plug 4 Inch
Sale

No12 Butt Plug 4 Inch

Earn $1.10 Loyalty Dollars
$21.95USD
Sale 19% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $5.49
Fur Bunny Tail Anal Plug
Sale

Fur Bunny Tail Anal Plug

Earn $1.40 Loyalty Dollars
$28.95USD
Sale 40% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.24
Ultra Soft and Bright Fox Tail Butt Plug
Sale
$31.95USD
Sale 21% Off
Add to cartAdd to cart
SezzleOr 4 Payments of $7.99
Page 1 of 2
Butt Plug Tails Articles
More
best bunny tail butt plug
Wanting to hop into some animal role play? This guide will show you the 6 best bunny tail butt plugs and give you some expert tips along the way! .
Posted in Sex Toy Guides
Butt Plug Tails
Butt-plug-tails-beginners-guide
Butt plug tails can be used as part of pet play or animal role play or they can just be a cute and fun addition to your anal exploration. .
Posted in Sex Toy Guides
Butt Plug Tails
shutterstock 1157639458
Get in touch with your wild side!.
Posted in Sex Toy Guides
Butt Plug Tails
The Heat Sex ArticlesThe Heat Sex Articles
Guest
16th June 2022
rating 4.0
Verified Purchaser
Had what I wanted at a good price. The only bad thing about the store is that it shipped from NEW ZEALAND and it took FOREVER for it to get here (by Chicago). didn't know this till they notified me about the shipment.UGH!
Guest
14th June 2022
rating 5.0
Verified Purchaser
Well packaged! I was very impressed by how quickly it arrived after learning it came all the way from New Zealand. Very affordable, and great quality toys. Extremely satisfied. I will be buying from ATMS again.
Rachel
9th June 2022
rating 5.0
Verified Purchaser
They have a great selection of items to choose from. Very good quality, and I received it very promptly. Definitely will be ordering from them again
Matt
8th June 2022
rating 5.0
Verified Purchaser
Shipping was prompt and packaging was sustainable.
Subscribe and be in to win a Cosmopolitan gift pack.Value $475.60. Valid all June. T&C's apply

TOP